Navigating Claims, Restoring Confidence

Our Story

Rooted in decades of experience spanning construction, property management, and property loss consulting, our team at Property Claims Advisors (PCA) has developed a unique approach to claims management that sets us apart. We’re more than just consultants – we’re your dedicated claims concierge, bringing together time-tested principles of integrity and cutting-edge technological expertise.

Our journey is defined by long-standing relationships and a deep commitment to those we serve. Many of our team members have worked together for years, creating a foundation of trust, technical prowess, and genuine care. We blend the reliability of old-school customer service with innovative solutions, ensuring that every policyholder receives comprehensive, compassionate support.

Our Mission

At PCA, our mission is to transform the property claims experience. We are dedicated to providing thorough, precise damage assessments while navigating complex claims with transparency and expertise. Our goal is to demystify technical challenges for our clients, delivering innovative solutions that expedite recovery and help policyholders return to normal life and business as quickly as possible. We approach each claim with a commitment to understanding the unique circumstances of every situation, ensuring that our clients receive comprehensive support and clear guidance throughout the entire claims process.

David Mistick

Founder & CEO

[email protected]
Rooted in Construction

David, the founder of Property Claims Advisors, brings decades of hands-on expertise in construction and restoration to the insurance claims industry. Raised in a family construction business, he learned the trade early, developing a profound understanding of building techniques that would define his professional journey. From single-family homes to complex restoration projects, David has transformed his early training into a comprehensive enterprise specializing in intricate and historic properties. His remarkable portfolio includes the restoration of hundreds of buildings listed on the National Register of Historic Spaces, establishing him as a leading expert in preservation and reconstruction.

Hurricane Hero and Restoration Pioneer

A pivotal moment in David’s career came with Hurricane Hugo in 1989, when he expanded his restoration division to support devastated communities. His expertise became legendary through his work restoring historic churches in Charleston and reconstructing properties in New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina. Throughout subsequent major hurricanes, David developed a reputation for resilient, comprehensive recovery solutions that go beyond standard restoration practices.

A Trusted Insurance Industry Expert

As founder of Property Claims Advisors, David serves the insurance industry with unparalleled specialized knowledge. He focuses on unique and challenging properties, bringing extensive insurance appraisal experience across residential homes, ocean-front complexes, and intricate historic structures. Frequently called upon as an appraiser or umpire, David leverages his distinctive background in construction, historic preservation, and insurance to navigate and resolve complex property damage claims with precision and expertise.

Why Choose Us

Empathetic

We understand the personal impact behind every property claim.

Innovative

Creating custom solutions for unique claim complexities.

Expertise

Decades of technical knowledge in property claims & construction.

Transparent

Committed to honest, clear communication throughout the process.

Dedicated

Your recovery is our mission, driving everything we do.

David's Testimonials

"For over 20 years, I have had the distinct pleasure and privilege of working with Dave as the nation’s leading authority and subject matter expert in the art of Historical and Sacred Space Restoration and Remediation processes. From college campus facility portfolio’s replete with centuries old buildings to high profile sacred spaces in virtually every metropolitan area in the US, Dave has engaged each project with the deepest respect, utmost care and with both precision and exactitude unrivaled anywhere. I have relied upon Dave to help chart the way forward on complex restoration projects under the most trying circumstances and highest expectations for success. In every circumstance, Dave has exceeded extremely high expectations by the most demanding clients. I have and look forward to continuing my partnership with Dave Mistick in his capacity as the “Best in the Business.” Anyone who has had the pleasure of working with Dave can attest to his professional acumen, relentless drive for excellence and high standard of ethical conduct in the most demanding circumstances."
John A. Kunert
Director, Business Development, NorthStar Recovery Services
"David and I have worked on multiple projects from Florida to Texas, including hurricanes, water losses, and fires. His knowledge and skills are an asset for dealing with complex losses. He stays on point, gets his estimates, and reports to you promptly. His communication skills for conversation with clients, contractors, adjusters, and counselors are another one of his strengths."
Gordon Welch, SLCA
Executive General Adjuster at McLarens
"Dave is excellent as an expert witness and as a consultant. Dave is a excellent choice for any large losses, and I would recommend him for any consultant or expert witness work."
Thomas Moody
Attorney
"I've worked with Dave on several complex losses and found his attention to detail and ability to work with others to be of great benefit."
Steve Whitmarsh
Chief Claims Officer | North America at McLarens